|
Why
Pet Lovers Oppose PAWS
PAWS does nothing to improve
the welfare of pets.
PAWS is poorly written and
has been interpreted by different attorneys to mean entirely different
things. No legislation should be passed for which the meaning is
not absolutely clear.
PAWS will invade the privacy
of thousands of Americans who breed and sell a few dogs or cats
each year.
PAWS is in conflict with the intent of the AWA: to regulate wholesale
operations but not home-based retail breeders.
USDA regulations are impossible
to meet under home breeding conditions, in which puppies and kittens
are raised in the house, socialized with the family, and treated
as pets.
PAWS would require thousands
of small-scale breeders to meet commercial standards of care, inspections
and record keeping.
Small scale breeders are already
subject to local and state cruelty and neglect laws. Animal control
officers are able to enforce those laws as needed.
Many small-scale breeders will
be forced to stop animal breeding entirely. PAWS will reduce or
eliminate the best sources of healthy home-raised, well-socialized
kittens and puppies.
PAWS will require most rabbit and bird breeders in America to be
USDA licensed, placing a much largerinspection burden on USDA. These
breeders are already covered by cruelty and neglect laws.
The number of puppies and kittens being mass produced and sold over
the internet is completely unknown. There are no statistics to justify
this legislation.
The federal government has
more important things to do with tax dollars than to inspect citizens
who want to breed their pets.
This legislation is obviously
a "foot in the door" for animal rights organizations that
want to see all breeders registered and inspected, and eventually
to end pet breeding altogether. We can be sure they will be lobbying
to lower the numbers as soon as the bill is passed.
|